Cornell & Diehl Crooner

(2.71)
A specially cut, cube-style burley and deer tongue tobacco, Cornell & Diehl's Crooner is an authentic copy of Bing Crosby's private blend, shared with C&D by one of his closest friends.

Details

Brand Cornell & Diehl
Blended By  
Manufactured By Cornell & Diehl
Blend Type Burley Based
Contents Burley
Flavoring Deer Tongue
Cut Cube
Packaging 2 ounce tin, bulk
Country United States
Production Currently available

Profile

Strength
Medium
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Extremely Mild -> Overwhelming
Flavoring
Mild to Medium
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
None Detected -> Extra Strong
Room Note
Pleasant
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Unnoticeable -> Overwhelming
Taste
Medium
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Extremely Mild (Flat) -> Overwhelming

Average Rating

2.71 / 4
35

36

28

21

Reviews

Please login to post a review.
Displaying 31 - 36 of 36 Reviews
Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note
Sep 23, 2022 Medium Mild to Medium Medium Tolerable
The word is this deer tongue ingredient happens to be one controversial additive. According to the FDA it’s really nasty stuff and candidly should be avoided at all costs. Other sources are not quite in consensus with those experts. Being a proto-typical generation Joneser, I naturally look upon any evidence of dissension with an ounce personal skepticism. As such, for me no problem indulging a pipe blend that featured the quirky substance frankly. Everything is good in moderation, right? Maybe you agree, maybe you don’t.

I will say that on the post-side of repeated smoking excursions, I was not left with an urgent compulsion to bleat or primordially grunt, let alone play a smashing game of Red Rover with a fast-moving box made of steel. Nor did I experience any adverse physical reactions to the same, all silly joking aside. As one would have it, Bing Crosby the ultimate crooner, and renown piper smoker, had a natural affinity for a custom-made blend of choice tobacco. A special mixture contrived just for him, aptly laced with a herd’s volume of this dubious deer tongued fu-fu, which brings me to my purpose …

From within Cornell & Diehl a forthright proclamation for the crafting an “exact” replica to one of Crosby’s most darling blended passions. A deed made possible from the disclosure of the original recipe from an insider to Bing’s own piping circle. For your entertainment the featured and often highly debated mixture Crooner. This melodious ensemble of tasty classic Burley and deer tongue licked tobacco professes to ring true as knelling of the bells of St. Mary’s. Truly a smokeable inspiration that would have delighted the heart of dear Father O’Malley himself some do righteously decree.

Based upon a thumbnail inspection, this medium strength recipe captures a collection of approximately 85%-90% roughly coarsened and ground cube cut Burley with a scant boon of actual yellow-white ribbon deer tongue leaves. Crooner’s pre-smoked body poses as a very gritty and grainy texturing, as the tobacco shows a heightened degree of perfected dryness. As such the packing and the ensuing burn are quite accommodating.

From the pouch the vibrant perfume of what I call lush “Indian sweetgrass” provides a delightful encounter. A rustic fully floral and honeyed essence wafts with a mocking of vanilla-like content. To me this bring images of autumn fermentation and natural aging, symbolic of the wealth and spirituality of the land. How’s that for fancy words?

Underneath this fore fronted aroma is predominantly a sharp base sourness and elderly wood emanating from the powerful Burley lying within. There is a bit of fervid zest as if Kentucky was steadfast present readied to light you up. Truthfully, Crooner’s nose is probably one of the most colorful and expressive Burleys I’ve yet to encounter to be straight with you.

Not knowing what to expect with the tasting, as I’ve heard some many tales, I was quite elated when the initial flavor registered. Although Crooner is billed as a sincere “deer tongue blend”, I didn’t necessarily experience it from that limited perspective. Granted this perceivably austere element is very notable, no question, but it has been tempered in a fairly complementing and congealed manner.

Categorically the sweetness rendered is broadly similar to vanilla but tends to be thinner and not as overly sugary. It is more dulled or respectfully contained, perhaps a better description I’m thinking. Additionally, the flavor did exhibit considerable charm in floral minty tones, pulling with it an abiding accent of refreshing bitterly spiced clove, indeed splendid. If what I sensed reflects the embodiment of deer tongue’s true features, then hey I like it man! Much character here folks.

And now speaking to the principal component, less I forget that yes, this is a Burley-based blend after all. Let me simply state that the quality of Burley presence is standard Cornell & Diehl. Given that, at least in my opinion, Burley is a specialty of this particular blender, means you connect with a wholesome and encompassing varietal profile.

Specifically, Crooner comes bundled with a strong and heady classic Burley taste that projects much machismo. If I didn’t know better, I would swear that there is DFK or Perique in this soup given the earnest spiciness of its tenor, especially on the retro hale. Mainly, that wonderful Cornell & Diehl Burley punchy gusto provides a zestful embellishment to the tobaccos tendency to be more comfortably woody. Modest attributes of creamier nuttiness do reside within the lower periphery, but Crooner does nonetheless favor the darker nuance. There is a nice level of herbal accenting, a clean shot of cooling mint, and finally earthen tart that helps to form its composite representation in general. Solidly intense and concentrated Burley flavor hands down.

Crooner produces an impressive volume of thick meaty smoke that carries a distinct air of the classic “pipey” Burley scent, deep, robust, and immodestly big within the immediate room area. Yeah, I use that cliché often because it’s so befitting, but mostly I like the way it sounds. This dark heavy essence is peppered and selectively seasoned with a dash of colorful floridness and added spice. Most likely tolerable but doubtful for those who are sensitive to expansive lingering odors.

Very simply Crooner is a fairly straight-up recipe that awards the piper with a touch of liveliness while being satisfactorily mellowing in effect. A couple of minor bumps I noted, however. There is a bit of harshness that formed at back of the throat periodically. Personally, I’ve become accustomed to the tenacity and the petty roughness of these particular Cornell & Diehl Burley strains, but just a heads up.

Even so, I experienced no real bite and would judge the nicotine effect to be placed in the middle of the road. Secondly, for being a conditionally dry mixture, it does leave a crap ton of dottle on the bottom of the bowl, and I do mean a crap ton. It felt like I was scooping out the used grinds from one of those old percolator style coffee filters in preparation of the next pot.

Honestly, Crooner was not what I expected, actually it was much more. Overall, I can see adding this blend to my Burley rotation as it provided just an edge of tantalizing difference. Not necessarily an aromatic, but it does demonstrate some of those softer features that has my own tongue wagging. It definitely trips my hardcore ”Burley Man” trigger without reserve. Maybe I’ll grab my best cob and go run the fields with the rest of the herd? Just be wise enough to avoid those pesky cars. Give it a try and see if you agree. 3.1 Pipes.
2 people found this review helpful.
Please login to upvote this review.
Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note
Mar 26, 2021 Medium Medium to Strong Medium Pleasant
Did Bing really smoke this?

The bag note has a floral note, reminding me slightly of lakeland style blends and their soapiness. The cut is cube cut with a mix of darker and lighter tobaccos.

I buy this in bulk. The moisture is perfect for packing. I smoke this in smaller pipes and find it easy to light.

The smoke seems to be dominated by the deertongue to my taste. There is some underlying nutty taste from the burley. It burns well. Doesn't produce tongue bite to me. I get a slight tingle in the roof of my mouth and tongue whenever I smoke it.

I find this one of those blends that I really enjoy a bowl of when I'm in the mood for it. It's not something that I'd grab regularly. I have a couple of aromatic pipes that I smoke it in due to limited ghosting.
Pipe Used: smaller princes and diplomats
PurchasedFrom: Smokingpipes.com
Age When Smoked: 2021
2 people found this review helpful.
Please login to upvote this review.
Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note
Feb 15, 2023 Strong Mild Medium to Full Pleasant
This is a great nightcap smoke. The burleys are woody, earthy, and nutty. The deertongue is nice compliment to them, offering an earthy grassy vanilla note. The deertongue enhances the room note. Crooner has a fairly strong nic hit, and I am no stranger to powerful blends. Despite being a strong burley-based blend it will only bite if you smoke it too fast.

The deer tongue will ghost your pipe, so pick a dedicated pipe for this blend. If this really is from Bing Crosby's private stash, I can see why. The deertongue does turn this from a simple burley blend into something far more interesting.
1 person found this review helpful.
Please login to upvote this review.
Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note
Apr 09, 2024 Medium to Strong Mild to Medium Medium Pleasant to Tolerable
What a pleasant surprise!

This was my first deer tongue tobacco, which is of little shock for a guy who's only been smoking for less than 1 year. I did not want to waste the full cost of a 2 oz. tin, so my friend and I split a tin. In retrospect, we BOTH should have purchased a tin a piece because we quite enjoyed the smoke immensely. Before I could buy the only remaining tin, my buddy quickly gobbled it up.

The fine cube cut had me worried about packing it too tightly, but it packed up nicely. The initial aroma from the tin was off Cinnamon Life cereal topped with vanilla extract. The charring light pillowed up quickly, so DO NOT pack to the very top of the bowl so as to not overfill during the char. A handful of relights, but otherwise smoked quite smoothly. The nic-hit stayed pretty medium throughout, but became a touch stronger near the finish. The smoke had the pleasant aroma of cinnamon, but only a hint of vanilla. The taste was a very burley forward, nutty flavor. No real tongue-bite to speak of.

My tobacco shop already has ordered a few more tins for my friend and I. I will keep this in my rotation as an early morning smoke accompanied by a strong cup of coffee. I recommend giving it a try!


Pipe Used: Rubino Full bent billiard
PurchasedFrom: Superior Smoke Shoppe
Age When Smoked: A few months
0 people found this review helpful.
Please login to upvote this review.
Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note
Sep 14, 2022 Medium Mild Medium Pleasant
I had a sample of this tobacco the other day at a Pipe show. I cannot fully describe the smell of deer tongue, but it kind of smells familiar to me despite the fact I never had it in my life. Having said that, the flavour profile dissipates quick and all you are left with is this beautiful burley blend with nutty and roasty notes so easy to smoke and no tongue bite. This is to say I fully enjoyed this blend and I am willing to buy a tin for myself, but at this point in time I can only give this review 3 stars because my experience is very limited in this sense. If anything changes after I smoke a few more bowls, I will come back and upgrade my review accordingly.
0 people found this review helpful.
Please login to upvote this review.
Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note
Mar 17, 2022 Mild Medium to Strong Medium Pleasant
Disclaimer, I bought this in bulk at my local pipe and tobacco shop under the name “Bing’s Fav” but am almost certain this is the same blend due to the cut of the tobacco, etc. When I first tried this years ago it was very, very fragrant of Deer Tongue. When I decided to try this again after reading a review with Deer Tongue my jar had pretty much dried out. I could still smell and taste the Deer Tongue, also called Dog Tongue or Vanilla Plant but obviously the years were not to kind with this blend. I must have bought this at least 5 years ago or so. One of the few blends I jarred and did not date. I still chose a pipe that I was not worried about ghosting which was an old cob. Not a bad smoke but one that for me I have to be in the mood for and apparently up until recently never revisited. I have enough that I will more than likely never buy a tin but interesting to try some. Apparently, way back in the day this was a very popular ingredient in pipe tobacco.
Pipe Used: Old Cob in case of Ghosting.
Age When Smoked: Around 5 years.
0 people found this review helpful.
Please login to upvote this review.

target="_blank"