How My Rating System Works: 1 Star: Bad, low quality, flavorless, evil, palate punishing or just plain uninteresting (which ever way you want to put it). You probably won't see that many one star tobaccos in my list of reviews because I rarely smoke them more than a handful of times and while reviewing bad tobacco can be fun, I'd rather not waste my time. 2 Stars: Most likely a quality mixture that for one reason of another I didn't fancy, or perhaps I just marginally enjoyed. I may finish the tin, cellar it away for later, or just gift it away, but most likely would not purchase it again. 3 Stars: A solid tobacco mixture, one that I would consider purchasing again, and perhaps one that I will grow to love. 4 Stars: Superb and for sure I have a few tins or more socked away. Most likely in one of my rotations. Yeah I have more than one. I am a Virginia's in the spring & summer, Latakia's in the fall and winter kind of guy.