Ashton - Brindle Flake pipe tobacco reviews

Review

Please log in to add or edit a review. If you do not have an account yet, you can sign up for one here.

Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Showing reviews 1 through 18 of 18 reviews of this tobacco
Kilmarnock Piper	10/04/2009	Medium	None detected	Medium	Pleasant
Got a ten-year old can of this on Ebay, and it is one of the best natural Virginia flakes I have had the privilage of trying. I savored that can, smoking small bowls slowly, until I had only enough for two more pipefuls, one of which I shared with my brother. I missed winning at the last moment another tin on Ebay (hope the winner likes it and posts a great review) and will watch out for more. I think this flake would continue to improve for ten more years. I would give possibly $30 for another can, though I usually don't believe in shelling out that much. It's quality all the way, and I wish it were still made. 5-23-10 I have acquired another sealed tin, which I will save for a special occasion. Really curious as to how the new reissue of this measures up. Buy some, and let's review, guys and gals! 7-13-10 Opened the (original issue) tin. Hope it blows me away like it did before. Will update! At the beginning of the bowl, this is not much different than the McClelland Christmas Cheer 2002 I smoked earlier. Opening up a little now: perhaps the reason it was so good the first time I tried it was that I had had only a couple McClellands then, but I'll wait to form a final judgment until I have had a couple more bowls. Certainly not a disappointment, but then McClelland seldom is. It's just less unique now, since I have had more McClellands! It is a bit richer than CC '02. The last half of the bowl will tell more surely. No, wait, I can see how it's different: CC '02 is very pure and mild, and you can not get it to bite. This Brindle Flake is a sipper-it can bite a little if you overpuff, though to do so is tempting. Ah yes, now I'm starting to remember. Lovely smoke!
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Jakob Kiilerich	10/16/2008	Medium to Strong	None detected	Full	Pleasant
First of all: I am from Denmark. The total sum of tobacco available in my country is either Danish manufactured or "colonial tobacco" - if such a substantive even exists anymore.. American-made "Heinz-tobaccos" (pardon my french) is totally unknown to most Danes. I had some experiences with this certain type of leaf before I tried Brindle Flake, and I was shocked and appalled. However: Brindle Flake made me convert. Next: Never mind the weird smell in the tin. Once lit, this tobacco opens up worlds of nuances in the taste department. The leaf is of extremely high quality; golden brown pure unspoiled VA, with a tang and sweetness that exceeds almost everything I've ever put in my pipe. My tins were three to four years old, and that is probably a good thing - read Pipestuds reviews and learn about the attributes of stoved VAs. (been there, done that, bought the t-shirt) I could imagine a fresh tin would burn any palate to cinders. I have dedicated two pipes for Brindle Flake, because I want it unpolluted. Said pipes will soon be used for other blends, since this one has been discontinued and I have only seven tins left. I hope the taste will linger for aeons.... (pun intended with the New-Age lingo) Jakob Kiilerich, Denmark
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
raadman	06/07/2006	Medium	Mild to Medium	Medium	Tolerable
Just like Orlik's Long Golden Sliced Flake except for the price...an online retailer has it on sale for five bucks a can. Don't worry, the tin aroma (burning tires, cat puke) will go away with all the extra moisture... The elegant, re-cycled plastic lid is a nice touch by Ashton... a really old sasieni
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
KingWilliam	04/11/2006	Mild to Medium	Medium	Medium to Full	Pleasant
To all the peasants that would past judgement on a fine leaf such as the Brindle Flake I say to you all - OFF with your Heads!Better yet- you're out of your heads!The richness that is obtained thru the aroma of drawing on my Reo Ferndown is unparallel to any can i've opened in the past 6 months.I must say the 5-97 mfg. date probably added a great deal to the sugar flakes that I so much savored . Then again, only the FINEST Virginia's are fit for a King!
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
A. Morley Jaques	02/22/2006	Mild to Medium	None detected	Medium	Pleasant
I don't know who McClelland's thinks they are fooling. Between their catfood-like tins and the aroma of tomato paste that whafts out when they are opened, no matter the tobacco therein contained, I could identify one of their blends if it was in a tin with a white label that said 'tobacco' on it in large block lettering. Nevertheless. I liked this flake moreso than nearly all others I have had from their line, which would be about all of them. With so many of their other flakes, I have noted that there is a basic McClelland's taste, just as there is a basic McClelland's smell, which asserts itself with different levels of intensity from one offering to another. In Brindle Flake we are given something more: it has that well known combination of tang and smokey musk that McClelland's does so well and seems that they will never give up, but with varying notes of fruit(peach, blackberry, whathaveyou), along with an occasional buttery, caramel--butterscotch--that's what I'm looking for--type of note. All of these elements fail to present themselves in any great force above the basic tobacco undertone, and the experience is rendered just a tad boring as a result. Steve Books of Rich's Cigar Store, Portland, OR had a limited supply of a hand cut, deep red Virginia Flake which he called Stonehaven, I believe. This was, far and above, the finest flake I have ever had. It served to further fix my notion that Mr. Books is the best we have in, quite possibly, the world today. Some of the everpresent but everchanging elements of taste that I picked up on in that Flake of Flakes I noticed in Brindle, once again, though, there is not enough of the expected complexity therein for me to get all too excited about it. Regards, A. Morley Jaques
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Pipestud	11/03/2005	Mild to Medium	None detected	Mild to Medium	Pleasant
This is a rather light offering for a flake tobacco which has the typical "McClelland's ketchup smell in the tin. The tobacco also contains a lot of moisture and will need some drying out before being consumed. And because of the moisture content, it burns with difficulty and will nip if not smoked carefully. Tongue bite, as most experienced pipe smokers know, can be caused by a variety of things, including one's own chemical makeup responding to the chemicals in a specific blend. Or, the simple fact that the tobacco in question is a natural flame thrower. Since I dried this blend out quite a bit before smoking and because I puffed very slowly, I tend to think this one is a naturally hot burning blend. The taste of Brindle Flake is just a bit rough around the edges but not unpleasant. Due to the bite factor, I cannot recommend this as an all day smoke. I can see where it will work as an end of the day smoke when one has more time to work carefully with the leaf and does not puff with vigor.
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Ian Weeks	11/03/2005	Mild	Extremely Mild	Medium	Pleasant to Tolerable
Okay, okay, okay- everybody knows that McClelland?s blends smell of catsup? Like some sort of VA salad dressing that none of us pipers can identify in anything but fragrance. But this one isn?t quite as strong, it has something much sweeter lurking in the tin. I can almost swear that when I put fire to this weed a heavenly cord rang out from above, and a light shone down illuminating me- I felt transfixed, at peace, one with the cosmos? Oops, sorry. That?s what happens every time I light a pipe. McClelland did a fantastic job with Brindle Flake, the tin is filled with beautiful golden broken strips of flaked VA, I grab the larger strips, fold and stuff them and then crumble the rubbed out bits on top to get things fired up properly. As for taste- it?s my opinion that this is a premium blend that doesn?t disappoint in the flavor department, there lay hidden in each bowl an unbridled powerhouse sweetness that develops the stoved rich body and roundness as the bowl progresses. I have read that some experienced tongue bite with Brindle Flake; I humbly beg their pardon but disagree. I have smoked this blend in every size and shape that I can and have had no problems with tongue bite. I found this blend to be tame, or perhaps it?s just me. A delightful Flake, highly recommended to the new or veteran VA smoker.
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Spike	08/05/2005	Medium	None detected	Mild to Medium	Tolerable
If the vinegar/ ketchup tirade bothers you, look elsewhere. Otherwise this is a very nice Virginia. One of my pipe pals gave me a few bowls of this and I thought it was an excellent smoke. A bit nippy like all pure Virginias, it seems to do best if lightly rubbed out, coarser tobac in the middle of the bowl and once well lit, smoke slowly and savor the taste. I think the key is the moisture level. The rubbed out flake needs to air dry for a bit but not to the crispy or brittle stage. If you live in a low humidity area, this can be accomplished by filling the pipe and waiting a half-hour to overnight before firing it up. You want the tobacco to have a little spring to it when pressed down lightly with the thumb. I don't know how to manage the drying process if you live in an area like the South or some of the Eastern United States. Maybe a wooden box with a small light bulb inside would do the trick.
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Beer	09/03/2004	Mild to Medium	None detected	Mild to Medium	Tolerable
A typical middle of the road McClelland-made Virginia, a bit drier than usual but with the usual great fruity/sour smell in the tin. It burns well, doesn't bite the tongue and has a nice delicate taste. Not as spectacularly tasty as some other Virginias by the same brand, but pleasant and OK for all-day use.
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
	12/27/2003	Medium	None detected	Mild to Medium	Pleasant
Brindle Flake is a very fine virginia that needed just a bit more rubbing out to suit my tastes. It is not overwhelmingly sweet, indicating no casing. It will provide a very pleasant smoke for virginia fanciers. A bit darker in flaver that an unstoved virginia, don't expect this to be an all-day smoke. It lit very well, was easy to keep lit, and provided the usual ample, yet airy smoke of a virginia blend. It was not at all vinagery in taste or smell. Just a delightful smoke. By the way, I smoked this blend in my XXX Ashton Pebble Shell...and I'm sure that made the blend smoke even better! Blimey, what pleasure!
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Pounder 5000	10/28/2003	Mild to Medium	None detected	Medium	Pleasant to Tolerable
How about some ketchup with that there pipe?!! J/K, couldn't help myself. McClelland should just stamp there name on any product that comes out of their factory, 'cause they'll never fool anyone. That being said, this VA is one of their better. It is a very rich smoke. Unfortunately, as Eulenberg put it best- there are lots better out there! It just isn't worth the tongue bite either. If you really, really, just had to have this particular flavor of smoke, you had better watch your smoking technique or else!
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
NEWMAN	06/13/2003	Medium	None detected	Medium	Tolerable
Based on the vinegar aroma in the tin, I would have suspected this as a McClelland blend in a blind test. The flakes in my tin were partially broken up and not so neatly packaged as other VA flakes but certainly not heavily rubbed out. An ideal moisture content permitted easy packing and lighting without further rubout. It smoked cool and without relights in various bowl sizes and required little attention. The taste is rather common to the McClelland 2000 & some of their Personal Reserve Series + some of the Butera's that are also McClelland products: slightly sweet and zesty. Overall this is a rather unremarkable but still enjoyable tobacco. I'd choose either the McClelland bulk blends due to price/# or Butera's Blended Flake that I find more interesting due to the added Perique and Orientals.
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
RCUSElder	05/20/2003	Medium	None detected	Medium to Full	Tolerable
While I generally am not a virginia smoker, to those who are, I commend this blend to you. Upon opening the tin, you are greeted by partially rubbed out flakes, and a tangy odor common to this type of tobaccy. It rubbed out and packed easily and lit easily as well. The tanginess that you smell in the tin does not come out in the smoke. Rather, you get a dark ,woodsy ,medium flavor that reminded me of my boyscout days. It developed a nuttiness toward the end of the bowl and smoked to a fine grey ash with no dottle typical of this blend. One warning though, you must smoke this sloooowwww, otherwise you will toast your tongue.To end, this is a good medium strength virginia blend,nothing special, but good, good, good. Recommended....
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Eulenburg	03/27/2003	Mild	Mild	Mild	Pleasant
Slightly peppery, with a semi-sweet chocolatish undertone (not a casing, just a feeling) this is a pretty good light flake. The catsup in-the-tin redolence I didn't care for AT ALL. There must be forty Virginia flakes out there better than this. But this is not bad.
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
howie	02/27/2003	Medium	None detected	Medium to Full	Pleasant
The following review was the result of a blind taste test: Sample A arrived dry and required additional moisture in order to adequately rub out or pack. The tobacco was partially broken upon arrival. The component tobaccos range from blond streaks through medium and on to dark brown. This tobacco smells like a McClelland to me, with the characteristic vinegar nose. My first bowl of this was in a medium sized Castello billiard, where I found it to be much too hot and caustic to enjoy or even really pick up any of the flavor other than thin heat. Within a few days, I came down with a cold, and it is possible that the lack of flavor could be attributed to that. I generally find that I have tongue bite problems with McClelland VA products and this was no exception. My second bowl was smoked in an older Lane Era Charatan poker that I have used only for VA and VA/Perique blends. This developed a good burning character once it got started, although it is still a bit hot on the tongue. The flavor is well developed, particularly in comparison to the thin flavor that was shown in the first bowl. Early bowl flavor character is bright with a citrus sourness. It is accompanied by a slightly metallic flavor and moderate body. While there is some sweetness, this is not a really sugary virginia. Mid bowl flavor has intensified and has sweetened considerably. There is a tendency to burn hot. At times, very hot. The tongue bite reduced considerably midbowl despite all of this. The third and final bowl of this was smoked in a gourd calabash and it really shined here. Early tongue bite was still present, but the richness of flavor was exceptional and the smoke temperature was acceptable. This was DGT?d overnight for the bottom third or so, and suffered no bitterness as a result. The flavor was muted, however, although smoking characteristics were good. The moderator asked that this be tried in flake and rubbed out form, with which I was unable to comply. I am rarely able to smoke flakes without rubbing them out, and given the difficulties that I experienced with the first bowl, I was unwilling to try and feel like I was going to be able to review. Given that I tend to stay away from McClelland products, this was a nice change of pace and o decent experience. I think that I may try additional flakes in the gourd, where the cool characteristics may do the job for me. I generally smoke about 15-20% VA or VA/P flakes, and tend to go in streaks of smoking and not smoking this type of tobacco. This was richer tasting than most that I have experienced for the type. Overall, I would rate this 80/100 for flavor, 50/100 for burning characteristics, and 60/100 overall, with deductions for the heavy tongue bite. February 2003
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
flint	01/05/2003	Medium	None detected	Medium	Pleasant
Absolutely delicious is this weed. It also reminds me of Benjamin Hartwells Signature Blend. Although this seems fuller and not overly sweet. It has wonderful low and high notes. A really good virginia flake. Brindle flake rubs out, packs, lights and burns great right down to a white ash a real clean tobacco. This flake has a wonderful smokiness to it not as citrusy as BJ's signature blend. This is a definate keeper I will be buying more of this to cellar. Highly recommended to virginia fanciers and flake fans. Happy New Year!!!
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Inquisitor	09/07/2002	Medium	None detected	Medium	Pleasant
If you like McClelland Virginias, you shouldn't pass this stuff by. Pipe-legend Paul Szabady identified Brindle Flake as the most full-flavored of the McC #2010 - McC #22 - Brindle Flake spectrum. Less lemony than its two siblings, it has a beautifully balanced zest note of apricot/peach in the top spectrum. A wonderful sweet and natural element passes without transition from the high range to the mid-range. The mid-range sweetness is butterscotchy, with toasted marshmallow flavors, again from the natural Virginias. The upper-bass zone carries a light-brown sugar tone, and a light-but-rich creaminess which perfectly balances the apricot zest. Like most good Virginias, Brindle Flake gets better and better until the end of the bowl sneaks up on you. Smoked best at just above a smoulder, this can bite you if rapidly puffed due to the high natural sugar content of the leaf. Hot smoking also obscures the wonderful nuances of this blend, which continue to evolve throughout the bowl. This is easily one of my favorite tobaccos. I'm always willing to take this stuff in trade, and I keep plenty of tins on hand due to its proven knack for getting even better with aging. BRAVO!
Reviewed By:	Date:	Strength:	Flavoring:	Taste:	Room Note:	Recommendation:
Tantric	07/05/2002	Mild to Medium	None detected	Mild to Medium	Pleasant to Tolerable
A good Va flake,easy to smoke, with a slight vinegar aroma (as common in McClelland blends, as the soapy taste in many English tobaccos). It reminded me very much of Ben Hartwell's Private Reserve/Signature Blend (which is also blended by McClelland). Nothing to get excited about, but a good, honest Va smoke. It burns very well, it has the right degree of moisture and it's easy to pack.
Showing reviews 1 through 18 of 18 reviews of this tobacco