tobaccoreviews.com
Current Stats:    tobaccos: 4421 (0 new)   /   reviews: 51427 (68 new)   /   Users Online : 759   /   full report > Hall of Fame Search:
[advanced]


My Account
Log In
Join Now
 
My Account
Browse Tobaccos
Add Tobaccos
Add Brand
 
Connect
RSS
Facebook
Blog
 
Help
Contact
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
 



Lamb Cake Slices

Brand: Kane's of New Zealand
Blender: Rutheford G. MacGillicuddy
Tin Description: Blended to accompany New Zealand's famous red wines, these meaty slices rub out easily to facilitate filling. Matured Virginias with Burley and a touch of Perique. An added essence gives Lamb Cake Slices it's rich and satisfying character. Add some Lamb to your line up.
Country of Origin: NZ
Curing Group: Sun Cured
Contents:
Burley
Virginia
Perique
Flavoring:
Mint
Cut: Broken Flake
Packaging: 50g Tin
Blend Notes: Contains real lamb juice and a hint of mint.

Images are temporarily disabled.



Average Ratings
Strength: Medium
Flavoring: Medium to Strong
Taste: Full
Room Note: Tolerable
Recommendation: Recommended


The Reviews  

Please log in to add or edit a review. If you do not have an account yet, you can sign up for one here.

 
Showing reviews 1 through 19 of 19 reviews of this tobacco
 
Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Stationmaster 02/20/2009 Overwhelming Extra Strong Overwhelming Overwhelming highly recommended
I know its poor form to review a tobacco that you haven't tried but stiff. Back in the early 70?s Mum and Dad used to take us kids to visit Nanna and Pa out in the Yarra Valley of Victoria, Australia. It was the bush back then. Dry sheep paddocks, horses, worn out ute?s and tractors, left where they stopped, and outside dunnies. All 6 crammed in a Morris Major and a seat belt was what you got if you played up. I remember Pa couldn?t see too well and he accidently cracked open a tin of Ham thinking it was his Kane?s lamb slices. He sliced off a chunk, as usual, muttered expletives as he rubbed it out, as usual. It took him about 5 minutes to get it burning right in his Barnsbury billiard, which was basically a Dunhill 35 shell knockoff. Amazingly the room note was very similar to what we were used to and as described in the reviews below, but maybe slightly richer and no minty background. He seemed quite happy until he got to the dottle which promptly caught fire. He stuck mostly to Erinmore mix after this, as you can only mistake that tin for boot polish, which is another story. I can only go on childhood memories as you can?t get this tobacco for love or money, old blend or new, even this close to our cousins across the ditch (choice Bro?s). I?ll keep an eye on eBay and if I?m lucky I?ll update this review. Whenever I smell an unattended BBQ I think of old Jim and his Kane?s lamb slices. Maybe I?m being foolish, but tonight I might thinly slice some Spam, dry it and add some mint flakes and----------------I?ve got to go. I?m getting all teary.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Pipe-billed Grebe 02/03/2009 Strong Very Strong Extra Full Overwhelming not recommended
IMO, pure rubbish, FTL. Utterly unpalatable and nauseating, with all the subtlety of a hoof to the head. I smoked this in a gorgeous S. Bang 7/64 bent zulu that is now fit only to be a chew-toy for my blue heeler.

IMHO, a much better pick for lovers of lamb (settle down, denizens of College Station, TX, not that kind of love) would definitely be Galafianakis' Gyros Flake, a masterful Balkan blend which beautifully balances several high-grade orientals (Katerini, Xanthi, Shawarma, etc.) with the drippings of succulent spit-roasted lamb and a delicate top-dressing of Tzatziki and cucumber. IMHBAO, a much more sophisticated blend.

Recommended.

Not.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
smokeemifyougotem 01/06/2009 Mild to Medium Medium Mild to Medium Very Strong somewhat recommended
Well, I'm going to have to be the voice of dissent. Aside from the tin aroma, this bears little resemblence to the original MacGillicuddy blend, which was heavenly. I would hazard a guess that Kane's is substituting Cavendish for the Virginia, as there is quite a bit more sweetness than I recall. The mint flavoring is also suspect. The original contained actual mint leaves, aged and kiln dried. The mint in the Kane's recreation tastes very much as if it came out of the same artificial flavoring bottle used to make mint chocolate chip ice cream... not that that's a bad thing per se. This is smokable, and even enjoyable to a certain degree. Admittedly, they did do a fair job of approximating the unusual "lambish-ness" present in the original, but if you're hoping to faithfully recapture the singular experience of MacGillicuddy's Lamb Cake Slices, you will undoubtedly be somewhat disappointed with Kane's version. Sadly, if you are a devotee of that blend, this is the closest you're going to get, so close enough has to do. Oh, and I almost forgot... you might want to smoke this in a cob as it will ghost the heck out of a briar.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Blackhorse 10/09/2008 Strong Strong Full Strong recommended
Good stuff, but you can't smoke it unless you dry it out quite a bit. The oven method works quite well. Then depending on the cut (which you actually have to do yourself) you can get quite a bit into a good sized bowl. Then, depending on how long you keep a flame on it, you can get billows of savory smoke. Quite a full flavor here...the mint is way in the background. Mom used to buy this regularly, and everyone in the family loved it, sitting around the old kitchen table, smiling their way through their bowls. What memories! Now, my wife won't have it in the house. Doesn't like the flavor OR the aroma I guess - plus she used to raise it herself and it breaks her heart to see it smoked. I'll give you all a good tip - take a whole clove of garlic and stuff in right in your bowl before lighting...or better yet, add the garlic before that oven heating thing. It may sound crazy, but it really, really works!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
ChasMundungus 04/16/2008 Strong Strong Very Full Extra Strong recommended
I was excited to find that both A. Wolff?s and M. Haddaugh Little?s carries this blend here in the States. My wife found the room note so severe (pace the other reviewers) that she sent me packing out of the house with a ?if you?re going to smoak that stuff, go out in the pasture!? Being a regular reader of the reviews on this site, I am amazed at how widely varied opinions are as to this blend?s strength. My hypothesis is that aging will mellow this stuff remarkably--I?ve bought a few extra pounds to age in the freezer. Aging should also eliminate the ?springy? packing I?ve experienced?it practically jumps out of the bowl (the air-pocket method helped a bit with this). When I opened the can it was very, very moist. The "ketchup" smell of McClelland's is nothing compared to this stuff. A few hours at 325 degrees fahrenheit in the oven brought mine down to the correct moisture level, although to me it still has a bit of a ?wooly? taste. I don?t know that I?ll put this in my regular rotation, but like some of the other pipemen, it just feels right to be smoaking this stuff in the spring. UPDATE: I've sent a photo of the tin which should appear soon (?)--it actually comes in 200g cans & carries the Kosher symbol--perfect for those about to begin Passover this weekend!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Xeneize 04/11/2008 Extremely Mild Extra Strong Overwhelming Overwhelming not recommended
Quite unique drugstore blend. I cellared some and it doesn't age well, as the lamb flavor developed into a mutton taste, with some notes of goat.

I can't taste no Perique here, but some Kentucky and a hint of cigar leaf. The mint is hardly noticed, but some pineapple that reminds of Erinmore and some EMP-like chicken taste.

Best enjoyed during meals.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Pipepundit 04/10/2008 Mild to Medium Medium to Strong Full Pleasant to Tolerable somewhat recommended
I am told - I do not know - that there is a comparable French blend, in which the agneau is pre-sale from Bordeaux, and there is the barest touch - juste une larme, messieurs - of a Premiere Grand Cru.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Pipemanuk 04/09/2008 Extremely Strong Very Strong Very Full Tolerable to Strong somewhat recommended
I have to say that this tobacco is one of the hardest to get hold of that I have ever come across. By the time I had got my hands on it I was almost so out of breath that the thought of actually smoking it kind of put me off. Not only that, but as I like to smoke the original, just cramming it in the bowl is practically impossible. I use a Group 26 bowl which has a special floor stand to take the extra weight.

I must say that I found the tobacco resisted all attempts to feed it Virginia or Burley or Perique...though it liked Ryegrass and to be honest I don't think the flavour suffered too much.

I'd give it 4 stars but for the continuous plaintive bleating.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
fourshephards 04/09/2008 Medium to Strong Medium to Strong Medium to Full Pleasant not recommended
Frankly, I was curious about this and once tried it found it to be too close to Royal Yacht, which is not made with lamb juice but Yak juice - hence the real name Royal Yak.

Jay


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Stuart Rankin 04/09/2008 Mild Medium to Strong Full Very Pleasant recommended
I was fortunate enough to come across this in bulk, so I bought a half-pound to smoke right away, and had the other half-pound freezer wrapped. I found it was very difficult to rub out, and in the end used the coffee grinder method. The taste was fine and meaty as others have noted, with a minty aftertaste, (think menthol cigarette). Unfortunately I was interrupted by animal rights activists going door to door. When I invited them in, they commented on the delicious room note - I didn't have the heart to tell them what it was. A word of warning - if you choose to DGT this, be sure to refrigerate because it starts to develop a funk after only a few hours at room temperature.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
English Bulldog 04/09/2008 Medium to Strong Mild to Medium Full Very Pleasant highly recommended
I came across a tin of this tucked away in the chiller at my local supermarket, pleasantly surprised I added it to my trolley. Upon opening the tin at home I was greeted with s smell akin to a lamb roast- mint sauce and all!

The slices in my tin were rather fatty, so I assume a wether must have gotten into the mix somehow, be that as it may it gave the flakes a superb burning characteristic. All in all highly recommended, no need for dindins after a bowl of this, although perhaps some roast potatoes and peas on the side would add to the enjoyment of this particular blend.

(As another reviewer noted DGT is best avoided especially in warmer climes)


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Jimmy Muraco 04/08/2008 Mild Medium Mild to Medium Very Strong recommended
The first thing I noticed upon opening the tin was the mint. Truly a testament to the master blender's use of a restrained hand. I also detected something else in the scent...similar to the McClelland "ketchup" smell but this was more like KC Masterpiece BBQ sauce. Spicy goodness!

The moisture content was more than I am used to as the slices seemed wet. Once I removed a couple of the slices I saw that the cause of the excess moisture was the beige water-like substance pooled at the bottom of the tin. This is more than likely the lamb juice. What a grand presentation!

The flakes are easy to compress and fill the pipe with. I used some of the juice to put on the top of the bowl for "kindling". At first match the lamb introduced itself (its name was "Lambchop") and soon the mint joined in. The room note was pleasant and my wife commented that she kept thinking it was Easter Sunday. This is definitely not your drugstore variety, but very top shelf USDA Grade-A lamb!

The bowl ended in a small pile of grey ash with no dottle or bone fragments. Very nice smoke but certainly not an all-day as I was too full after smoking one pipe that I skipped dinner and went to bed.

On a side note, I understand that Greg Pease is working on a lamb blend as well but his will incorporate Cyprian Latakia, some dark rum, Latakia and more Latakia. It is to be the first in the new "Muttons and Maidens" series.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Stacey 04/08/2008 Very Mild Medium to Strong Medium Pleasant highly recommended
A kiwi friend of mine brought me a tin of this back after visiting the homeland recently. Everyone should be so lucky to have such a great friend.

My greasy hands were trembling in anticipation as I popped the top on the tin. The tobacco was moist to the touch with just a bit of coarse white hair mixed in. Lambs wool? I dunno. Anyway, I fired it up and first impressions were it was a bit minty. The wool-like stuff definitely improved the burn as it was easy to keep lit. About a third of the way down the bowl the mint taste settled down and now a deep meaty taste developed that would only increase, eventually tasting a bit like carmelized meat on the grill. Surely this is what burnt sacrifices were like in biblical times and so the whole experience was just heavenly!

Incidentally, unlike Pagercat's experience, my tin contained no "beige water-like substance" in the tin.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Sasquatch 04/06/2008 Mild to Medium Medium to Strong Medium Strong not recommended
I hardly detect any flavoring at all.

I far prefer Gravy Flake - much saltier and just a lot more satisfying.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Geoff 04/05/2008 Mild to Medium Medium to Strong Overwhelming Very Strong not recommended
This tobacco is fine when young but a bit of age brings out a mutton or hogget flavour which can be unpleasant to some.

The tin I had must have been from the rear end of the days production run as it was rather daggy when rubbed out.

Bruce and Trev who work at Kanes say there could be a redneck version coming out soon called two tooth this has yet to be confirmed.

Not a tobacco I shall try again Dunghills Dingo Flake is a much better tobacco in my opinion.

Below is a link to an article about the happy little sheep on their way to to be tinned. http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2004/04/03/1080941724083.html


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
DUPE.629 04/05/2008 Extremely Mild None detected Extremely Mild (Flat) Unnoticeable not recommended
"Pipestud"

Is this another one of you're April Fools Joke's???

Gae.I live in Australia,close to new Zealand,and no one has even heard of it!!!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
mo 04/03/2008 Medium to Strong Strong Very Full Very Pleasant highly recommended
I must admit that I did not want to smoke this. This is THE perfect blend if you need nicotine and nourishment. Can you imagine satisfying both nicotine craving and hunger in one go? How convenient is that?

The taste is fantastic and when I smoke this I usually have a nice garnish to the top of the tobacco, I find some coriander works best. To me the taste really reminds me of having a nice juicy chop and I noticed more teeth marks on the mouthpiece of my pipe. I obviously did not know this and my wife brought to my attention that I was in fact chewing on my pipe.

The only problem I have is that this blend has to be smoked indoors. The reason for that is that the neighbourhood dogs can get really persistant when they get a whiff of this delicious blend. The other day I was smoking this while driving, when I got to the end of the street, there were tens of dogs chasing my car. There was a petite young lady walking her St Barnard that was not impressed at all since the pooch pulled her along. Weird

Do not smoke this while out in the bush somewhere, I am sure Lions will follow the scent

Thanks you Pipestud

Mo, South Africa


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
loosewatches 04/02/2008 Very Mild Medium to Strong Full Very Pleasant highly recommended
I have a friend from New Zealand who's name, coincidentally, is Kane. Must be a popular name there. Anyway he sent me a sample of this luscious blend and for that, I am grateful.

The base tobaccos here are top quality and, surprisingly, not at all overpowered by the ladled on topping. I admit I was afraid to try this at first knowing that it 'contains real lamb juice` (just what is Lamb Juice?) but I'm glad I did. The sweet gamey flavor compliments the leaf nicely. It could use a nic boost, but hey nothing's perfect, eh? I also recommend adding 5% crushed mint leaf. Leg of lamb in a pipe. Perfect! (almost)

p.s. I'd like to thank Pipestud for the historical information. Nearly brought a tear to my eye to think this great smoke could be lost forever.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Pipestud 04/01/2008 Mild Very Strong Very Full Pleasant highly recommended
It has been quite some time since I last tried a tin of a Kane's of New Zealand tobacco. I was delighted when I recently discovered that their signature blend, Lamb Cake Slices, is back in production. The MacGillicuddy recipe for Lamb Cake had been lost years ago in a barbecue pit when heirs of Rutherford G. MacGillicuddy were having a family reunion by roasting lamb chops. From what I understand, it was an annual family tradition to work up a batch of Lamb Cake Slices in the same pit that Rutherford used to make this tasty blend. While putting together the ingredients, a strong wind blew the recipe out of the hands of a granddaughter right into the fire. My tobacconist tells me that after more than 20 years of trying to recreate the original, a great grandson was able to reconstruct the components to perfection.

What makes Lamb Cake Slices so unique is, of course, the casing sprayed liberally on the Old Belt Kentucky leaf which is then mixed with quality Virginia and Perique before being pressed into cakes. I remember how cautious I was in trying my first bowl after learning that the topping used was actually freeze dried leg of lamb (roasted and triple basted), that had been crushed and sprinkled throughout the tobacco. Once I finally lit up, I was glad I did!

Lamb Cake Slices is a very mild combination with a very strong essence of lamb taste. The combination somehow works as the smoker detects a meaty taste throughout the bowl. It does stay lit well and burned evenly down to a clean, snow white ash. Highly recommended!


 
Showing reviews 1 through 19 of 19 reviews of this tobacco
 

 


home back to top
2001-2013 SpecComm International, Inc. All rights reserved. Individual reviews are the opinion(s) of the contributor and don't reflect the opinion(s) of SpecComm International. Published review content of this website is considered the copyright intellectual property of the reviewer and SpecComm International and may not be reproduced in any manner without the expressed written consent of SpecComm International.

Real Time Web Analytics