tobaccoreviews.com

Tobacco Reviews is 100% user funded. Please help keep the site running.

Current Stats:    tobaccos: 3639 (0 new)   /   reviews: 35945 (107 new)   /   Users Online : 474   /   full report > Hall of Fame Search:
[advanced]


My Account
Log In
Join Now
 
My Account
Browse Tobaccos
Add Tobaccos
Add Brand
 
Support
Friends of TR
Donate
Support The Site
 
Connect
RSS
Facebook
Blog
 
Help
Contact
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
 



Grand Orientals: Smyrna No. 1

Brand: McClelland
Blender: McClelland Tobacco Company
Tin Description: Back when Istanbul was Constantinople, Izmir tobacco was Smyrna. "A rose by any other name..." These tiny, top-grade tobacco leaves from mountainous Western Turkey across from the Island of Khlos have long been prized as the most aromatic of all Orientals. They grow dense and extremely fragrant in this dry country moistened by Mediterranean Sea breezes. Smyrna is the defining ingredient in this sophisticated Oriental blend.
Country of Origin: US
Curing Group: Air Cured
Contents:
Virginia
Turkish
Cut: Ribbon
Packaging: 50g Tin



Average Ratings
Strength: Mild to Medium
Flavoring: None detected
Taste: Medium
Room Note: Pleasant to Tolerable
Recommendation: Highly Recommended


The Reviews  

Please log in to add or edit a review. If you do not have an account yet, you can sign up for one here.

 
Showing reviews 1 through 20 of 21 reviews of this tobacco
Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
7formy1911 08/23/2010 Mild None detected Mild to Medium Pleasant highly recommended
I've been holding off on this review for a bit because I almost expected myself to get tired of this blend but I haven't and find myself wanting to smoke it more and more. In the past anything that had a large percentage of orientals just did not sit right with my mouth and throat. I particularly remember Red Rapparee and how acrid the orientals were and they just seemed to hit me right in the back of the throat. I had almost given up on oriental leaves and figured they weren't for me. Boy was I wrong.

Enter Smyrna No. 1. To this point in my pipe smoking I have not found a blend that I really liked in a meerschaum. Smyrna No. 1 changed that as well. It is absolute perfection when smoked in meerschaum. The Smyrna leaves are brought to the fore front and the virginia base provides a rock solid altar on which the Izmir (Smyrna) leaves are offered to God in thanksgiving for this blend.

I have a sensitive tongue and I think that is why burley and English blends find their way into most of my pipes. This blend is quite easy on my tongue despite the Virginia and Smyrna. I certainly have to take it slow but even a faster puffing rate didn't hurt me much at all. I liked the Virginias so much that I'm actually looking at McC Virginia blends to find something I like.

In any case the taste notes are as follows: There is a sweetness to the Virginia that is certainly not overpowering but it is evident. The Virginias add body and provide a great back drop for the Smyrna. With the Smyrna I detect hints of cinnamon along with a mild spiciness and other warm spice notes I can only liken to mulled cider. It honestly reminds me of Christmas spices if that makes any sense.

When all is said and done I truly enjoy this blend and it has given me renewed hope in finding some wonderful Virginia/Oriental mixtures. I think the McC Grand Oriental line has hit a home run and I'll continue my quest through their other Grand Oriental offerings.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Deckard 07/23/2010 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Very Pleasant highly recommended
This has become my favorite blend. It packs and burns easily, has the most wonderful tin and room note, and the perfect balance of sweet and spicy flavor.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
BriarBurner 07/03/2010 Mild to Medium None detected Mild to Medium Tolerable recommended
The dominant feature in this blend is the sweet/spicey orientals that really pop with slow steady draws.I found this to be an easy packing, smooth smoking, no bite tobac. The strength is no powerhouse, but the flavor delivers throughout the bowl, As for room note, I could care less. I have found that in 45 years of pipe smoking what people think of my tobacs' smell is a non-issue, compared to the enjoyment I get from some of the more foul smelling blends out there.. Enjoy


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
AZ_Smoker 06/18/2010 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Pleasant highly recommended
This is one of the outright smoothest, creamiest and delicious tobaccos I have ever had the pleasure to smoke. It smells so wonderful in the can that you almost think you could eat it with a spoon. Ketchup and vinegar? I think NOT! For those of you who have smelled the fragrance of fresh-ground 100 percent Kona Coffee..... then add the aroma of a fine Oriental tobacco.... That is what wafts its way past this set of nostrils, in my humble opinion. So what's not to like? By the way, this tobacco goes exceptionally well WITH a cup of 100 percent dark roast Kona made espresso style.

Needless to say, I am impressed with this one. So much so that I have dedicated two of my finer meerschaum pipes to it. Well, ok, I use them for the Samsun, too, but you get my point. My wife wants me to smoke it on a fairly regular basis...... she likes the aroma that much! Finally, one my wife enjoys almost as much as I do.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Marshall Law 05/10/2010 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable highly recommended
This puppy really settled down and mellowed out after opening and leaving it to rest in the tin for a week or two. Yet another winner in the Grand Orientals series. Smyrna is similar in some ways to Samsun and the much lighter Katerini. By comparison, however, it is richer and more dense than Katerini, and a bit darker and more earthy than Samsun, with what could be perceived as undertones or suggestions of fig, cinnamon, and some other light spices. It is a bit two-dimensional and simple on the palate, but its focused, balanced flavor is sufficient to carry it on its own merits. Like the rest of the series, it lights and burns flawlessly, down to a light grey powdery ash, with no goop or mess. Won't bite or burn hot, but if you go ballistic on it and puff like a freight train, it can dry and numb the back of your throat, like most Turkish blends with a fair amount of nicotine. Prefers to be sipped and savored from a small bowl to explore its smooth, rich flavor, or worked more intently from a large bowl to kick up its spicier side. Unlike Katerini which is more delicate and better smoked in the morning or early afternoon, this is an all-day anytime smoke with plenty of flavor, but still smooth, mild and sweet. Tasty Turkish satisfaction. Well done. Three and a half stars.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Eric Cioe 03/05/2010 Mild to Medium Extremely Mild Medium Tolerable recommended
I support the idea of the Grand Orientals series so that we can get an idea of what individual leaves taste like. This is the only one I've had and I'm reviewing it from memory, but with a full tin under my belt I felt like I could say some nice things about it.

The presentation is impeccable with the two leaves atop the ribbon. Such a nice touch. I found this stuff a bit hard to keep to lit, but then I smoked my tin pretty fresh and didn't let it dry out at all. It left my pipes a bit moist in the bottom, which was no big deal, but worth noting.

The flavor itself was really ... rich and exotic, I guess. It wasn't a very deep blend in my experience, but while it was a bit one-dimensional it was a good dimension.

In short, I bought this mainly out of academic interest in the Smyrna leaf but ended up enjoying the smoke itself well enough to consider buying another tin eventually. Worth a try if you're interested in orientals at all.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Pipestud 02/02/2010 Very Mild None detected Mild to Medium Very Pleasant highly recommended
This is the template for sweet, light and spicy Oriental leaf. John Cottons made Smyrna leaf famous many years ago. While often imitated (sometimes somewhat successfully), I've never found anything quite like it... until I tried this McClelland's Grand Oriental Smyrna #1.

It is absolutely delightful. Although lacking in the strength that I normally gravitate toward, the flavor was delicious and slow puffing brought about a palate pleasing smoke.

Easy on the tongue, easy to load, light and keep lit, my puffer meter is pegged!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
don1688 01/26/2010 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Tolerable highly recommended
Wonderful stuff. The VAs are of the usual McClelland quality and smell amazing in the tin. The Smyrna adds a lightly spicy tone in the tin as well.

I find the smyrna very noticable at the first match and then settles in behind the sweet VAs and is always there.

Smoked slowly it is very flavorful, but if puffed somewhat quikly it starts to taste like a quality VA only- losing the orientals contribution.

Must try for VA lovers.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
SteelCowboy 01/25/2010 Mild to Medium Extremely Mild Mild to Medium Pleasant highly recommended
I am pretty split on the Grand Oriental line in terms of my likes and dislikes. Along with Samsun, I really enjoy this one. I think the best way to approach Smyrna is to enjoy is slowly. Puffing will not bring about a deeper more complex smoke. This tobacco scores big points because it is what it sets out to be, a delicate, light, sweet smoke. I enjoy this most in the mornings. Highly recommended!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
sagesmoke 01/22/2010 Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable recommended
Light, airy, somewhat sweet and clean.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
WmZiggy 12/14/2009 Mild to Medium None detected Mild to Medium Pleasant highly recommended
To add to the trivia regarding this blend, you can see the hole in the Smyrna leaf where each leaf is strung for curing. Can you imagine running a needle and thread through each leaf and the quantity it takes to make a pound! Ok, that said, this is wonderful tobacco. The light, spicy, almost cinnamon-like flavor and sweetness develops after lighting and one settles into this smoke. This blend has a wonderful complexity moving between suble sweetness and cinnamon and other taste notes. As with oriental leaf, it is light, soft and smooth. My guess - and I stress guess - is that this blend contains Maryland to enhance burning qualities, and a red Virginia to deepen the sweetness. The tobacco is a ribbon cut. It burns to a nice white ash. It was not wet on opening the tin, nor did it have the ketchup or vinegar smell McClelland is often noted for. It does not burn hot, nor bite. This is a light and nice smoke any time of the day.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Alguhan 08/14/2009 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable highly recommended
McClelland made a nice surprise and has placed a uncut leaf at the top of the tin content. I still remember the tobacco fields nearby my grandpa's town, very close to Izmir. Those tobacco plants had the same leaves as the one which I've found in this tin. The tobacco is at a nice grade of humidity but I also aired it a bit. So the well known sour McClelland smell settles well. Packed and lit very easy.

With first puffs a sweet and creamy flavor occupies the mouth and immediatelly the spicy taste adds its presence. Till the half of the bowl the spices are at background and then they take the main appearence, giving a delightfull and gentle strength to smoke. It is hard to smoke this tobacco because it is very tasty. But be patient and smoke it as slowly as possible, otherwise it leads a hot smoking. With a slow burning it will satisfy your flavor and strength needs better. Ends with a clean and soft ash.

This tobacco is one of the best oriental blends I've ever tried. With the other blends of this series it will be in my routine for sure.

While smoking this tobacco I remember my mom's stories. When she was a little kid she and her brothers were helping their neighbours for harvesting these tobacco leaves. They've had very nice childhood days on those fields. Who knows, maybe I am smoking now the leaves harvested by those neighbours' grandchildren!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
flagg1122 07/13/2009 Medium to Strong Mild Mild to Medium Pleasant to Tolerable highly recommended
I really love this blend. Great everyday smoke. It is a great late evening tobacco, the spicy almost cinnamon flavor is truly relaxing after a hard day. Recommended!!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
DK 06/17/2009 Mild None detected Mild to Medium Pleasant recommended
Call me easily amused, but I think it's way cool to pop a tin of tobacco and find two full leaves on top! I found this to be a mild, spicy blend with delicate but noticeable flavor. I did not find this to be full flavored at all, as many of the reviewers did. Instead I found it subtle, with nuance upon nuance, and very complex. I liked the roasted nuts comparison, and I agree.

Again, this McClellands Grand Oriental is worth trying but I did not find enough here to bring me back to it. Still, I think it's a marvelous achievement for McClellands and I suspect it will have its share of devotees. The Classic Samsum is probably the only one of the series I will smoke regularly.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
oldsouth 05/28/2009 Medium None detected Medium to Full Pleasant highly recommended
Once again another excellent blend. Mike and Mary have sure done their homework on this one. It amazes me at what lengths they will go, in order to secure the best leaf, so that we may enjoy these rare and exceptional blends.

Realizing peoples taste vary, but to me ,it is reminiscent to sweet toasted nuts! By far one of the best orientals on the market. It is a blend I will put in my rotation daily.

Thank you McClelland. Keep sending the pipe smokers the best.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Slow Triathlete 12/19/2008 Mild to Medium None detected Mild to Medium Tolerable somewhat recommended
Short review this time.

When compared to GL Peases's Embarcadero, which is also a Virginia/Izmir blend, this blend fails miserably.

The Izmir/Smyrna is extrmely muted in this blend and doesn't come to the forefront the whole time. It's there sporatically but not enough for my tastes.

Do yourself a favor and get the Embarcadero instead. It is usually cheaper and burns a lot better.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
fmichaelnv 08/02/2008 Mild to Medium None detected Mild to Medium Pleasant to Tolerable recommended
Is there anyone else tired of hearing that McClelland's blends smell like "catsup" or "vinegar" in the tin? As far as I'm concerned, it doesn't matter what a tobacco smells like in the tin: what matters is how it tastes and smells in the pipe.

The first time I tried Smyrna No. 1 was in a churchwarden outside in my backyard in a slight breeze with a dark Greek coffee. That was a mistake (not the coffee). The tobacco burned fast, slightly hot and tasteless. I figured it was much too light for my taste.

Shortly thereafter, I wanted to give this tobacco another chance; but this time indoors. I tried this fine blend in an old, small GBD pipe from the far end of my pipe rack. I made some Greek coffee again, which I love to smoke with any tobacco, and lit this tobacco in my basement.

The flavors are there but subtle. I can understand why I missed out on the cool, slightly sweet, spicy, peppery taste outdoors. I especially liked the taste on my tongue at the end of drawing on the smoke. The smoke was creamy, full and the oriental taste light. The smoke dissipates quickly. There is absolutely no bad aftertaste. The tobacco packs easy and smokes dry all the way to the bottom of the bowl to a fine grey ash.

I think it an ideal blend in a small pipe, indoors and should be smoked early in the day. I don't know yet if it will be part of my regular rotation, but when I'm looking for something subtle and exotic early in the day I may turn to this blend more often than not. I will always keep a tin around.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Psyktek 06/01/2008 Mild None detected Mild to Medium Pleasant highly recommended
Still working on the first bowl of this new blend in the Grand Oriental series. A very different direction from the first offerings in this line, I think McClelland has a real winner! A fruity, raisin-like quality in the first aroma from the tin does not carry thru in the bowl. Herbal, light, complex flavor and aroma is present immediately. If set aside, a vanilla component is apparent from the unlit bowl and, after relighting, an entirely different profile is presented. It's a little hard to keep lit at first, I think it would benefit from a brief drying out. Definitely worth trying, if only for a tobacco that is very different.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
cbd2 06/01/2008 Medium None detected Medium Pleasant highly recommended
Just as I finished my first tin, and was ready to write a review, Pipes & Tobaccos jumps in with a review that says it all (and I urge all to read). Rather than sum up what was written there, however, this was the review that I was writing in my head as I smoked...

The tin aroma is sweet and fragrant and the blend packs and lights nicely right out of the tin. The sweetish taste only remains in the first couple of puffs and then it's an array of spices - an array that can't quite be pinned down but similar to that found in a fragrant tea. And that's what you find in the remainder of the bowl: a spicy, not overly-sweet, cool smooth smoke that is a delight to the palate.

This blend is now on my "favorites" list. I also found, having just a bit of "Larry's Blend" remaining, that this mixes well with a blend heavy on Latakia in a mixture of about 3 parts Larry and 1 part Smyrna. I would suggest that others might use this as a blending leaf, as well.

BTW - it's also very cool to find your very own, smokeable, leaf at the top of the tin!


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Lochinvar 05/28/2008 Mild to Medium None detected Full Tolerable highly recommended
The best in the series! It displaced Samsun! This is sweet rich acidic satisfying, one of the greatest tobaccos on the market today (they are sure to cancell it now). It starts of dry and then develops the rich, spicy exotic oriental taste, soon followed by a virginia with a flavor like freshly cut clover hay. I am putting as much as I can behind. If you smoke no other tobacco this year than Smyrna, you have spent the year well. If you dont like it, dont smoke the rest of the tin, send it to me.


 
Showing reviews 1 through 20 of 21 reviews of this tobacco

home back to top
©2001-2010 Jon Tillman. All rights reserved. Trademarks and copyrights incorporated herein are the exclusive property of the referenced entity. Individual reviews are the opinion(s) of the contributor and probably don't reflect the opinion(s) of Jon Tillman. Published review content of this website is considered the copyright intellectual property of the reviewer and Jon Tillman and may not be reproduced in any manner without the expressed written consent of the reviewer or Jon Tillman.