tobaccoreviews.com

Tobacco Reviews is 100% user funded. Please help keep the site running.

Current Stats:    tobaccos: 3639 (0 new)   /   reviews: 35945 (107 new)   /   Users Online : 470   /   full report > Hall of Fame Search:
[advanced]


My Account
Log In
Join Now
 
My Account
Browse Tobaccos
Add Tobaccos
Add Brand
 
Support
Friends of TR
Donate
Support The Site
 
Connect
RSS
Facebook
Blog
 
Help
Contact
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
 



Blakeney's Best Acadian Ribbon

Brand: McClelland
Blender: McClelland Tobacco Company
Tin Description: The best sweet, tangy matured Virginias meld with subtle, cool Perique in an easy-to-pack, rich ribbon blend, smoothed by the Blakeney exclusive toasting process.
Country of Origin: US
Curing Group: Flue Cured
Contents:
Virginia
Perique
Cut: Ribbon
Packaging: 50g Tin



Average Ratings
Strength: Medium
Flavoring: None detected
Taste: Medium
Room Note: Pleasant to Tolerable
Recommendation: Recommended


The Reviews  

Please log in to add or edit a review. If you do not have an account yet, you can sign up for one here.

 
Showing reviews 1 through 20 of 21 reviews of this tobacco
Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Demetri 04/30/2010 Medium None detected Medium Pleasant highly recommended
I picked up a tin of this at my B&M several months ago, maybe 6 or 8. It was on a close-out special and I just added a tin to a multiple blend purchase at the time as an afterthought. Tossing it into my tobacco cabinet and forgetting about it, it languished away, ignored for months, until I ran out of C&D Bayou Morning, my usual morning smoke. Not wanting to smoke a flake in the very early AM I finally opened this. What a waste of time. NO! Not the blend, but my waste of sheer enjoyment. Now I'm kicking myself not buying several tins of this when I could get it for cheap. Cracking the tin I found, thankfully, no McClelland ketchup, if you know what I mean. Instead the tin aroma recalled fruit - and not the usual raisin, plum, fig fruits one usually reads in descriptions, but one of my favorites -sweet pineapple. The ribbon cut appeared to be heavier in Perique over the VAs. At first light, however, that impression did not follow through. The sweet VA's play first chair with the perique second. Still spicy enough though and the pineapply impression upon firing yields to a toasty almond note and ample nicotine to jump start the day.

Absolutely divine. A blend I must have more of. 4 Stars.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Ring88 03/03/2010 Medium to Strong None detected Medium Tolerable recommended
I was lucky and got this in a free tin. I do not care for the fist smell of this in the tin. Catsup is a very good way to put it.. but I can look over that, Packing was a breeze I did the three pinch. The charring light went well, The burning light went well. and then it hits you.. This is a great smoke strong in the perique wow spice.. Loved it only had to relight two maybe three times. just a touch on the ashy side in the end but all in all I did like this a lot. (relights may be my fault)


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
chgo.piper 11/26/2009 Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable highly recommended
sweet and tangy virginias with just the right amount of perique and is sure to age well and only get better. I believe this to be the best vir/per blend by McClelland and of course has that delicious sweet and tangy aroma of matured virginias that only McClelland produces... VERY well done...


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
DK 01/27/2009 Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable recommended
I have a theory that VaPer blends work best and taste best when they are in flake or broken flake form, rather than ribbon cut. This theory has no basis in actual fact so far as I know, but this blend lends credence to the theory. It's most likely comparison in the flavor department is McClellands Bayou Slices, another of Blakeney's Best. Both blends work well and taste good but the Bayou goes beyond that into a realm of depth of flavor that this one can't quite match. As usual, I find that ribbon VaPers cannot touch blends like Escudo, McClellands St James or #2015 and several others I prefer.

That said, this is a fully serviceable smoke. It is quite tasty and more than just reasonably satisfying. The cut ensures an easy load into the pipe and negates the need for relights. If you like the taste of perique, this blend won't steer you wrong. If it weren't for the existence of VaPer flakes, I could live quite comfortably with this one. Compared to those, this just barely misses the mark. It just doesn't possess the complexity of a flake, in my humble opinion. But those who don't want to mess with flakes will be very pleased with this. It's a nice flavorful smoke.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
SirLoirn 03/27/2008 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable somewhat recommended
Tin: The strongest raisin ketchup odor I remember, of all the McClelland blends. It was so strong, it was the only odor. It was difficult to isolate the Perique out of this. It was almost dry. Strong mahogany hue, overall, bespeckled with darker and lighter ribbon cut, the blonde being wide ribbon.

When smoked, the tin was 1-2 years old. For interesting info. on dating tinned tobacco, link to:

pipes.org---locate the Forums box--Topics--Tobacco Questions-- scroll down , to bottom of page, to Archive Oct. 03, 2006 and Archive Oct. 24, 2005.

Lighting: Oddly enough, it was not easy to keep lit, even though it was dry to the touch, when originally put in the pipe, producing some gurgle and moisture out of the stem. During one of the relights, half way down, it gave a sizzling sound.

Taste & Aroma: More flavor developed around mid-bowl. The Perique ketchup odor was distinct from start to finish; no tongue bite; not sweet.

The Perique quality developed late in the bowl, a peppery feel.

Smoked similar to Royal Cajun Special, in having a toasty VA character.

Laid down a tar and moisture in the pipe.

Nicotine: When the bowl was about done, a only a slight buzz was produced.

Room Note: Nice toasty strong VA. The ash had a vague cacao aroma.

Overall: BBAR is a mild VA billed as having strong and heady Perique. It seems to be designed for those wishing to smoke a blend with Perique, but still having a pleasing room note. The bowl smoke sure gives the nose a zing.

The thought of smoking something with a raisin ketchup signature not distinguishable from Perique, from tin to ash, is not a pleasant thought; could not rightly discern the McClelland from the Perique aroma. 2.2 stars.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
wosbald 11/10/2007 Medium to Strong None detected Medium Tolerable to Strong highly recommended
The tin aroma suggests caramelized fruit. This comes rubbed out in a mixed cut of flakey chunks, fine ribbon, and choppy medium ribbon. It loads with grace and quickly settles into an easy burn.

The base leaf is toasted gold VA to which a good dosage of perique is added. The rich flavor is nutty, sweet, and caramel-like.

This is a very companionable blend with just enough depth to add an extra level of satisfaction and which seemed best in a narrow gauge chamber.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
loosewatches 11/10/2007 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Pleasant recommended
I liked this one quite a bit. The toasting is definitely nice touch. Acadian ribbon is really well melded and smooth. It is also, as claimed, very easy to pack and burns with no problems. This is a good morning smoke for those who don't want too much strength to begin the day.

For me this is a change up smoke, though I could see it as an all-dayer for some. McClelland keeps putting out really good products. Now I'm going to have to try me some Grand Orientals.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
pipinNfishin 10/10/2007 Medium to Strong Extremely Mild Medium Pleasant to Tolerable highly recommended
This blend is smooth. The toasting process took the rough edges out of the virginia. Though not wet, I allowed the tin to dry for a few hours. I like my tobacco dry.

Characteristics are: Sweet Smooth Dry But not very complex.

Not bad, if normal vapers have bite for you, then try this. I find this med. to strong in nicotine strength. I am a daily Dunhill smoker. Use that as a guage for strength.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
sasha 01/14/2007 Mild to Medium None detected Medium Pleasant somewhat recommended
A good blend, though not exceptional: smokes cool, dry and biteless, the strenght grows up towards the end of the bowl and the amount of Perique is just right not to overwhelm the Virginia. It is a good all-day smoke for the VAPER lovers but I've found it a little boring, without any evolution in taste.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Fazby 09/26/2006 Medium None detected Medium Tolerable recommended
I enjoyed this. It is a nice Va with some perique added. This could come close to or become an all-day smoke.

My tin has about a year and a half on it.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Satc001 08/27/2006 Medium None detected Medium Pleasant to Tolerable somewhat recommended
Opening the tin, you are greeted with a wonderul looking tobacco. I love the ribbon cut, looks good, and is great to pack. Let this one air out a bit, it comes pretty moist, but give it a second to breathe then light up and enjoy. This tobacco fluctuates from being sweet, peppery, and raisin like, to ashy and bland. I don't understand what causes it to have either effect. Sometimes it is very enjoyable and other times not at all. I orginally rated this well but must lower it to two stars, a blend needs to be consistently enjoyable.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Elkabong 07/22/2006 Mild to Medium None detected Medium to Full Pleasant highly recommended
This was a Christmas present, and it's almost enough to make me believe in Santa again. I smoke a lot of Va./Perique blends, and expected a ho-hum experience. What a pleasant surprise!

I don't consider it strong -- in fact, I hesitated at terming it Mild to Medium. One of the other reviewers mentioned Frog Morton in comparison, I believe, but I don't see it. I use Frog Morton to smooth out Holiday, and consider it a blending tobacco. But this is a bit more assertive, which I like in Virginias, but without bite, and without falling into harshness. I couldn't bring myself to rev things up, because it was so pleasant to puff along. Perhaps it could be pushed into being bullyish, but I haven't found it so.

This is going to become part of my regular rotation, and I'll be cellaring some, too, to see what a few years does for it.

Highly recommended.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Cactus John 12/20/2005 Medium to Strong None detected Very Full Tolerable recommended
I am a big fan of Virginia /Perique blends. This one is about the strongest I would want to have Perique in a blend. It is border line to overwhelming. But it never crosses the line. Not for the beginner to Perique's. It does get stronger as you smoke it but somehow never gets to strong.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
miracleman83 09/23/2005 Medium Extremely Mild Medium Pleasant recommended
This is the best perique blend that I've tried. I haven't tried too many, but it's still the best. Latakia is my fav. As you smoke down the bowl, it gets more and more tangy. Like nothing I've ever had. It may be the virginia that is tangy, if so I need to try more virginias. I don't like all Va blends, so I'm guessing it was the perique that did it for me. Beats tawny flake in my book hands down. If you like Va, then try TF as well. Will buy again down the road.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Pipestud 09/02/2005 Medium None detected Medium Unnoticeable recommended
This blend was shared at the tobacco bar of my most recent pipe club meeting and I liked it so much that the fellow who brought it gifted me the tin and there were actually several bowls left after everyone had plowed through it.

The nicotine and Perique presence both get stronger on down the bowl, and the new "toasting" method used sure eliminated any bite. I did catch the typical "McClelland's ketchup smell in the tin, but it was quite subdued. I normally do not care for blends with Perique. But, this stuff was an exception. The Virginia base was sweet and not at all grassy. BTW, from what I understand, McClelland's may be the only pipe tobacco company with a large remaining stash of St. James Parish Perique. I have heard there is a cigarette company that pays high dollar for the stuff to put in their particular brand of weed. St. James Parish, Louisiana (the only place in the world where true Perique is grown) was not affected by Hurricane Katrina and future crops have not been compromised.

Finally, it says on the tin, "...rich ribbon blend, smoothed by the Blakeney exclusive toasting process." So, what is the Blakeney exclusive toasting process? Inquiring minds want to know.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
ajaj 08/28/2005 Mild Extremely Mild Mild to Medium Pleasant somewhat recommended
I am dissapointed by this new offering from McClelland. I can taste the "toast" but very little of the perique. I had high hopes since I am a fan of OGF, 5100, 2010, and 2015. Well, the toasting process not only elimates the bite, but practically eliminates the sweet virginia flavor I look for in McKethup. I've tried this in a variety of bowl sizes and disfferent times of day but it just does not click. DGT is pretty awful and ashy. The quality is there, just not my cup of tea.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
RCUSElder 08/08/2005 Medium None detected Medium Strong not recommended
Appearance and Tin Aroma: I love the typical MC tang and love many of MC's blends, but this one smelled like burned plastic IMO. The leaves were in a nice ribbon cut with mohogany, golden, and black leaf pretty much evenly represented.

Initial Flavor: Burned Plastic

Mid-Bowl: Burned Plastic with Perique tartness

Bottom of Bowl: More burned plastic, more Perique tartness.

Overall: As you might have guessed, I did not like this blend. It appears to be a high quality offerring, but did not agree with my palate at all...now where's my aged Blackwoods flake?


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Stan 07/01/2005 Medium to Strong None detected Medium to Full Tolerable recommended
Stan to the rescue, after trying a tin as usual. I have more stashed. Not a bad blend at all and a not too distant cousin to the Frog Morton series. The difference here is no latakia note or as dark of a finish.

VA. ribbons composed of stoved, red, and even some brights. That combo is what makes the taste here a little lighter in effect that any of the Frog Mortons. Not a weak blend by any means.

Throw in some perique and the flavor develops mid-way down the bowl to a small spicy kick. Not terribly complex or dark tasting or strong, but complex and spicy enough to suit a medium smokers taste.

I think a stoved virginia connoisseur may appreciate the added light leaf and perique influence. Recommended to that breed.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Blackie 07/01/2005 Mild None detected Mild to Medium Tolerable recommended
I'm with Stan on this one. This gets interesting to downright tasty about half way through the bowl. As un-impressed as I was with the other Blakeney's offering (Waaayyyyyyy too mild, bordering on tasteless), I think this is a winner.

Obviously the Perique carries the blend and, in my opinion at least, takes the Virginias to a much higher level. It is just that synergy that makes Perique magic.

I find myself reaching for the tin of this stuff and craving it. It is not the best of McClelland by a long shot, but I can honestly say that I like this and will be buying more to cellar. There is no doubt it will age well.


Reviewed By: Date: Strength: Flavoring: Taste: Room Note: Recommendation:
Zone Smoke 06/28/2005 Mild to Medium None detected Mild to Medium Pleasant to Tolerable not recommended
I tried this new blend from McClelland at the prodding of my local tobacconist. I found the blend to have the same Heinz vinegar smell as any of their blends containing virginia tobacco. The perique aroma was noted but was overwhelmed by the stench of the vinegar.

The tobacco packed easily and was a one match light. However, it is a mediocre, one dimensional smoke at best. There is nothing in this blend to make me want another bowl much less buy a tin.

If it's a virginia/perique blend you desire, do yourself a favor and invest in a better tobacco such as Escudo or Just For Him Golden Cashemere. This tobacco was a dismal effort.


 
Showing reviews 1 through 20 of 21 reviews of this tobacco

home back to top
©2001-2010 Jon Tillman. All rights reserved. Trademarks and copyrights incorporated herein are the exclusive property of the referenced entity. Individual reviews are the opinion(s) of the contributor and probably don't reflect the opinion(s) of Jon Tillman. Published review content of this website is considered the copyright intellectual property of the reviewer and Jon Tillman and may not be reproduced in any manner without the expressed written consent of the reviewer or Jon Tillman.